SAVE
Business

The Power of Giving Effective Feedback: Do It Right!

Few people come to work to do a bad job. Mistakes and errors usually arise because of weaknesses in working processes – workloads are stretched; skills, experience or training are lacking; operating procedures are poorly defined, impractical or unenforced. In general, these issues are not the fault of the person doing the job.

Feedback, should, therefore, focus on the weaknesses in the system, not on the character failings of the individual (which will be resented).

The Power of Giving Effective Feedback: Do It Right!

Learn from the Best

Eric Lofholm
Master Sales Trainer
Keynote Speaker
EntrepreneurNOW Network

Subjects of Expertise

Sales Skills
Motivation
Mindset & Strategies
TJ Walker
Bestselling Author
Personal Development & Habits Expert
EntrepreneurNOW Network

Subjects of Expertise

Communication Skills
Public Speaking
Personal Development
Arvee Robinson
Master Speaker Trainer
Bestselling Author
EntrepreneurNOW Network

Subjects of Expertise

Public Speaking
Persuasive Presentations
Lead Generation
Brad Hussey
Web Designer
Marketing Consultant
EntrepreneurNOW Network

Subjects of Expertise

Web Design
Online Business
Freelancing Career
Carol Marzouk
Executive Coach
International Speaker
EntrepreneurNOW Network

Subjects of Expertise

Leadership
Employee Engagement
Valerie Sargent
Emotional Intelligence Strategist
Award-Winning Business Leader
EntrepreneurNOW Network

Subjects of Expertise

Emotional Intelligence
Leadership
Sales
Scott Robertson
Certified StoryBrand Guide
Public Relations Expert
EntrepreneurNOW Network

Subjects of Expertise

Public Relations
Marketing Communications
Attraction-Based Marketing
Paul Banoub
Technologist
Leadership & Productivity Expert
EntrepreneurNOW Network

Subjects of Expertise

People Management
Productivity
Leadership

Specific Feedback is More Helpful than General

It is just as important to give positive feedback where it is due, as well as negative feedback where it is needed.

Relate the feedback you give (positive or negative) to a specific event or action, and describe in detail the context and what was good (or not) and why. We learn better when feedback is relevant and directed at specific actions or activities.

Earn As You Learn

Earn 25% commission when your network purchase Uplyrn courses or subscribe to our annual membership. It’s the best thing ever. Next to learning, of course.

Earn Learn Image

Give Positive Feedback First

The general rule is to give positive feedback before negative because many people become blinded by the negative feedback and don’t absorb what comes after. Nevertheless, this should be used with care because people can get wise to it in a way that means that positive feedback is not received in the spirit it is intended, but becomes a warning signal for negative feedback to follow!

Don’t Shy Away from Negative Feedback

Negative feedback can be hard to impart, particularly if you work closely with the recipient. But negative feedback is not the same as a disciplinary warning. Rather it should be a constructive discussion about what went wrong, why, and what the actions should be to ensure it never happens again. As noted, people rarely set out to make a mistake; and we usually know when we have messed up, or something has gone wrong. Negative feedback shouldn’t be a surprise; the key thing is to structure it so it has a mutually positive and empowering outcome, rather than a demoralising one. There are six elements to this:

  1. Give the feedback privately. Negative feedback should not be given in a public forum (unless very minor). The feedback and discussion should take place in a private place. Its content is no-one’s business (unless disciplinary action is required).
  2. Criticise the process not the person. This makes the feedback feel neutral rather than personal and pointed. It also makes it easier to agree improvement actions.
  3. Focus on specifics. Errors arise at a specific point in a process. Seek to identify the process weaknesses, and discuss what can be done to rectify them. Again, this neutralises the feedback. Focusing on specific events and actions also makes learning from mistakes easier.
  4. Invite the individual to give their point of view. There are two (or more) angles to every story. Encourage the person whose performance you feel to be below par to describe the events and issues leading up to the problem from their point of view. This allows them to explain themselves fully and will help you understand the person’s actions in a different light.
  5. Invite the individual to consider the situation from other points of view. Often those involved in the heat of an issue look at it only from their own perspective. Invite them to consider the situation from the point of view of others involved (for example customers or colleagues) and discuss the potential impacts of the event or action on them.
  6. Agree an Action Plan. The outcome of the negative feedback should be positive – an action plan designed to get everyone back on track and to resolve the problems identified in working procedures. Ideally, the action plan should contain work for both the recipient of the feedback and the person giving it. What support is required to help the person improve? This may be training or shadowing; a review of procedures; or other actions that need management approval.

You can also check out my online courses here.

Ross Maynard
Featured Uplyrn Expert
Ross Maynard
Chartered Accountant, Process Improvement Coach
Subjects of Expertise: Process Improvement, Performance Measurement, Problem Solving
Featured Uplyrn Expert
Ross Maynard
Chartered Accountant
Process Improvement Coach

Subjects of Expertise

Process Improvement
Performance Measurement
Problem Solving

Leave your thoughts here...

Find Your Place in The World

Top Companies choose Uplyrn to look for Talent.